What's the Difference Between Painting and Staining a Wood Deck?

calander May 17 , 2023 user-iconAnderson Painting

A wood deck is a beautiful addition to any home's outdoor living space, providing an ideal spot for relaxation and entertainment. But decks are often exposed to elements that could cause the wood to fade, warp, and rot. Paint or stain gives your wood deck an added layer of protection to prevent all those issues while enhancing your deck’s appearance.

But what is the difference between painting and staining a wood deck? Is it better to paint or stain a deck? In this blog, you will find the answers to these questions.

Painting Vs. Staining

Painting and staining are two popular methods of enhancing the appearance of various surfaces, such as wood, metal, and concrete. Both involve the application of a liquid substance onto a surface to achieve a specific look or function.

The painting process is familiar to most. Painting is the process of applying a thick, opaque coating onto a surface to create a colored, protective barrier. Paint can be made from various materials, such as oil, latex, or enamel. You can apply it on walls, furniture, decks, and other surfaces.

The primary purpose of painting is to provide a protective layer to help a surface withstand wear and tear, weather conditions, and UV rays. Of course, you can also use it to add some color and enhance the look of a surface.

On the other hand, staining involves the application of a thin, translucent liquid onto a surface to enhance the natural color and texture of the material. Stains are typically made from a blend of dyes and pigments, which can highlight the natural grain pattern of the wood. Unlike paint, you can apply stains only on porous materials like wood.

Pros and Cons of Painting Your Deck

Paints come in different types. Not everything will be suitable for your wood deck. So, if you choose to paint over stain, learn about what kind of paint to use on a wood deck. And find out both the pros and cons of this finishing option.

Pros of Using Paint on Decks

More Color Options

Wood deck paint can transform a plain, unattractive deck into a beautiful, eye-catching feature that complements the rest of your home's exterior. It can cover any imperfection, giving your deck a fresh look without a costly replacement. There is also a vast range of colors available, allowing you to create a unique, personalized look for your outdoor space.

Protection for the Wood

Paint creates a protective barrier on top of the wood, sealing it from moisture and sunlight. It helps prevent damage from rot, insect infestations, and UV radiation.

Long Lasting

If you are asking, “What lasts longer on a deck: paint or stain?” the answer would be paint. High-quality deck paint can last 10 years or even longer. It may develop problems like cracking or peeling, but it is repairable.

Low Maintenance

Painted decks have a slick surface, making it easier to sweep away debris, dust, and dirt. You may still need to deep clean the deck at least once a year.

Cons of Using Paint on Decks

Pricier Than Stain

Painting even a small deck can set you back a hundred dollars or more. This is because you need more than just the paint for the job. You also have to purchase other things like a primer and sealer. The process is also quite extensive, so the labor costs for those planning to hire a pro tend to be higher as well.

Slippery When Wet

Painted decks can be slippery when wet, creating a safety hazard, especially for children or the elderly. If you plan to use your deck frequently or live in a high rainfall area, consider using an anti-slip additive or textured paint to improve traction.

Difficult to Remove

Switching to a different color or finish after painting your deck will be challenging. Removing old paint can be a time-consuming, labor-intensive process. You may need to use chemical strippers or sanding.

Pros and Cons of Staining Your Deck

If you wish to enhance the natural beauty of wood, stain is a great option. But like painting, staining comes with disadvantages. Learn about the pros and cons of this option below.

Pros of Using Stain Finish on Decks

Enhances Natural Beauty

Unlike paint, stain highlights the wood's natural grain pattern and texture instead of covering it. It creates a more natural, organic look that complements the surrounding landscape and adds warmth and character to your deck.

Easy to Apply

Like painting the deck, staining the deck will still require you to prepare the surface. However, a stain is generally easier to apply thanks to its runny consistency. You also do not need to worry about lap marks because of the stain's transparency.

Cons of Using Stain Finish on Decks

Limited Color Options

Unlike paint, which offers virtually endless color options, stains have a more limited range of hues and finishes. While this can be a disadvantage for those who want a specific color, it can also be an advantage for those who prefer a more natural, understated look.

Requires Regular Maintenance

While stains are generally low maintenance, they still require regular cleaning and reapplication to maintain their appearance and protection. It is especially true for semi-transparent and clear stains, which can fade or wear off more quickly than solid stains.

Can Be Prone to Mold and Mildew

Applying too much inexpensive oil-based stain to your wood deck may create an environment where mold and mildew thrive.

Does Not Cover Imperfections

Unlike paint, stains do not cover up imperfections on your deck, such as other stains, discoloration, or surface damage. So this option may not be ideal if your wooden deck is not in its best condition.

Paint Vs. Stain: Which Is Better?

The best option boils down to your preferences, the type of wood in your deck, and the intended use of the surface.

Paint can be a better option for those who want to change the look of the wood surface. It offers more color options and can be customized to suit any design scheme. It also provides better protection against moisture and UV rays, which can cause wood to rot and fade over time.

However, paint can be harder to apply than stain and requires more maintenance. It can chip, crack, peel, and will require repainting every few years.

On the other hand, stain is for those who want to maintain the natural beauty of the wood. Stain penetrates the wood fibers, protecting them from the inside out. It is easier to apply than paint and requires less maintenance. However, stain is less effective at protecting against moisture and UV rays and may require more frequent reapplication.

If you need help deciding between wood deck stain or paint, a professional like Anderson Painting can give you valuable insight. Don't hesitate to get in touch.

Call the Pros

Staining or painting a deck may seem like a great project to add to your DIY list. But before deciding to do the task yourself, consider the perks of professional painting and staining.

Professional deck staining or painting contractors have the experience, skills, and equipment to deliver a high-quality finish. You can be sure it will protect your deck against weathering, rot, and decay.

Additionally, reliable pros use top-quality materials that will last longer and provide better protection than off-the-shelf products. So, save yourself the hassle and trust the pros to get your deck looking its best.

If you need help staining or painting your wood deck, don't hesitate to call Anderson Painting today. Our team can do both finishes and guarantee a satisfactory result.


If you enjoyed this content, browse our other articles:

Five Ways to Customize Your Concrete Flooring for the Perfect Look

Beyond its durability and versatility, a concrete floor offers a blank canvas for customization. Learn five ways to cust...

Choosing the Right Colors for Commercial Spaces: Psychology and Branding

The paint colors you choose for your commercial space can make or break your business. Make sure to pick a color that wi...

Hiring Professional Painters for Winter Interior Projects: What to Look For

Avoid botched painting jobs and get the best bang for your buck. Learn several variables to consider when searching for ...